Baseball has always been part of the Hibbitts family story. Cliff Hibbitts spent years coaching baseball, and his son even played professionally. With all the Hibbitts kids growing up around the game, baseball became more than a sport—it became a way of life. That's why you'll see baseball woven throughout the shop. It's our way of celebrating family, teamwork, and making memories.

We make our own vanilla extract! Our homemade vanilla extract is crafted using vodka and real vanilla beans. It takes time to develop its rich flavor, but we think great ice cream is worth the wait.

Like many small businesses, we've seen the cost of ingredients, packaging, and transportation increase. Higher diesel fuel prices have made shipping more expensive, which affects nearly everything that goes into making and serving our ice cream. We remain committed to using quality ingredients while keeping our prices as fair as possible.

It all starts with our ice cream machine. Unlike many manufacturers, we don't rely on artificial stabilizers or preservatives to achieve a smooth texture. Instead, our process uses precise temperature control to create exceptionally creamy ice cream with a cleaner, fresher taste. It's an old-school approach that lets the ingredients shine.

Absolutely! We'd love to be part of your big day. Give us a call or stop by the shop to schedule a tasting. We'll help you create the perfect ice cream experience for your wedding or special event.

Because everyone has a favorite! We rotate many of our candy and cheesecake flavors throughout the year to keep things fresh, fun, and exciting. That means there's always something new to try—and your favorite will be back before you know it.